Olympic Rule 50 and political neutrality: is it time for a turning point?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30937/2526-6314.v6.id160Keywords:
Olympism, rule 50, neutralityAbstract
Since 1955 the Olympic Charter (OC) declares that there must be no extraneous events within the Olympic Games (OG), in particular of a political nature. The so-called Rule 50 has banned the use of the Games to externalize one’s ideas. Its infringements were mostly due to symbolic behavior by athletes who were then punished despite demanding respect for fundamental human rights trampled on in many regions of the world. The first question this essay poses is: is the rule an unjustified impediment to acting for just cause? Recent international political events and in particular the Russian-Ukrainian armed conflict have sparked renewed interest in the declared apolitical and neutrality of the Olympic Movement (OM) and its effectiveness in promoting peace and achieving the goals of Olympism. The second question of this essay is: is this positioning always reconcilable with real events? It will be concluded that the current rule 50 adheres to the rules of international law while neutrality should be rethought and sacrificed if it makes the pursuit of the objectives of peace and justice less effective. The two issues are independent but can act in complementary ways to pursue legitimate objectives of the OM.
Downloads
References
IOC. Olympic charter. Lausanne: IOC; 1955.
IOC. Olympic charter. Lausanne: IOC; 1974.
IOC. Olympic charter 1975. Lausanne: IOC; 1975.
IOC. Olympic charter. Lausanne: IOC; 2021.
Mulraney F. The Irish Olympian, forced to compete for Britain, who smuggled in an Irish flag [cited April 19, 2022.]. July 22, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.irishcentral.com/roots/history/peter-oconnor-irish-olympian-flag.
Urbsintacta. 1906, Peter O'Connor and the 1906 Olympics [cited April 19, 2022]. 2014. Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jll6laPUCEg.
Olympics.com. Blast from the past: blood in the water. Olympics [cited April 19, 2022]. April 27, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/en/news/blast-from-the-past-blood-in-the-water.
Nittle NK. Why black american athletes raised their fists at the 1968 Olympics [cited March 5, 2022]. www.history.com. May 25, 2021. Available at https://www.history.com/news/black-athletes-raise-fists-1968-olympics.
BBC. Rule 50: a history of protests at the Olympic games [cited April 19, 2022]. https://www.bbc.co.uk/ [Online]. June 5, 2021 Available at https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/57357068.
Sommerova O. Doc alliance - A silent protest [cited April 19, 2022.]. Youtube.com. 2012. from 36:28 to 37:50. Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xsLhH57Zai4.
Gibson, Owen. London Olympics: athletes who refuse to compete will be 'heavily punished' [cited March 9, 2022]. www.theguardian. [Online] June 14, 2012. Available at https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2012/jun/14/london-olympics-athletes-refuse-compete.
Davidovich J. Still refusing moment of silence, Olympic head says memorial will be held in Germany [cited March 9, 2022.]. www.timesofisrael.com. July 22, 2012 [Online]. Available at https://www.timesofisrael.com/still-refusing-moment-of-silence-olympic-head-says-memorial-will-be-held-in-germany/.
Reid-Smith T. Olympic Committee threatens to punish athletes who fight for gay Russians [cited March 9, 2022.]. August 12, 2013 [Online]. Available at https://www.gaystarnews.com/article/olympic-committee-threatens-punish-athletes-who-fight-gay-russians120813.
BBC. Ethiopian Olympic protest runner Feyisa Lilesa finally rewarded [Cited April 9, 2022]. BBC. [Online] April 10, 2019. Available at https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-47879919.
The New York Times. How George Floyd died, and what happened next [cited April 19, 2022]. www.nytimes.com. November 1, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.nytimes.com/article/george-floyd.html.
Smith JA, Keltner D. The psychology of taking a knee - The backlash against protests by Colin Kaepernick and other athletes raises all sorts of scientific questions [cited April 19, 2022]. blogs.scientificamerican.com. September 29, 2017 [Online]. Available at https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/the-psychology-of-taking-a-knee/.
Schofield C. What does take the knee mean? How people are using the gesture to show solidarity with Black Lives Matter [cited April 19, 2022]. www.scotsman.com. June 9, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://www.scotsman.com/news/uk-news/what-does-take-the-knee-mean-how-people-are-using-the-gesture-to-show-solidarity-with-black-lives-matter-2879387.
BBC. What's taking the knee and why is it important? [cited: April 19, 2022]. www.bbc.com. October 13, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.bbc.com/news/explainers-53098516.
Zhicheng H. George Floyd protests given huge boost as football authorities soften stance on athlete activism [cited April 19, 2022]. news.cgtn.com. June 4, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-06-04/George-Floyd-protests-given-boost-by-soccer-body-s-ruling-R2KKr4g9hu/index.html.
Maguire J. Globalization and sport: beyond the boundaries? Sociology. 2011;45(5):923-929. DOI: 10.1177/0038038511413432.
Global Athlete. Global athete statement on Olympic Charter Rule 50 [cited April 9, 2022]. Global Athlete. June 14, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://globalathlete.org/our-word/ioc-rule-50.
Coventry K. IOC Athletes’ Commission’s recommendations on Rule 50 and Athlete Expression [cited March 5, 2022]. https://olympics.com/. April 21, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/athlete365/voice/ioc-athletes-commissions-recommendations-on-rule-50-and-athlete-expression/.
Access. Raven Saunders on X protest at Olympic ceremony [cited April 19, 2022.]. www.youtube.com. 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7M8gJSjThk.
Brennan C. USOPC says shot putter Raven Saunders didn't break rules related to athlete protests [cited: April 2022, 2022]. https://eu.usatoday.com/. August 02, 2021 [Online]. [Cited: April 2022, 2022.] Available at https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/christinebrennan/2021/08/02/us-olympic-shot-putter-raven-saunders-didnt-break-rules-protest/5451081001/.
USOPC. U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee informs athletes of rules regarding demonstrations at U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Trials. Team USA [cited: April 20, 2022]. March 30, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.teamusa.org/Media/News/USOPC/033021-USOPC-informs-athletes-of-rules-regarding-demonstrations-at-US-Olympic-and-Paralympic-Trials.
Grassi D. Olympic sport does not ban Russian and Belarusian athletes (although there may be signs of change). Olimpianos - Journal of Olympic Studies. 2022;6:60-92. DOI: 10.30937/2526-6314.v6.id154.
Pavitt M. USOPC will not sanction athletes for protests as Council on Racial and Social Justice calls for Rule 50 changes [cited: April 20, 2022]. www.insidethegames.biz. December 10, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://www.insidethegames.biz/articles/1101840/usopc-protest-position-council-rule-50.
IOC. IOC EB recommends no participation of Russian and Belarusian athletes and officials [cited: March 05, 2022]. https://olympics.com/. February 28, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/ioc/news/ioc-eb-recommends-no-participation-of-russian-and-belarusian-athletes-and-officials.
IPC. IPC Code of Ethics. Bonn, Germany: IPC; 2021.
IPC. Supplementary Regulations - Paralympic Games Tokyo 2020 demonstrations. Bonn, Germany: IPC; 2021.
IOC. The IOC AC’s recommendations on Rule 50 - Q&A document. Memorandum. Lausanne: IOC; 2020.
IOC. Resolution of the IOC Executive Board with regard to racism and inclusion [cited April 20, 2022]. olympics.com. June 10, 2020 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/ioc/news/resolution-of-the-ioc-executive-board-with-regard-to-racism-and-inclusion.
IOC. Athlete Expression Consultation - Quantitative research results [cited April 21, 2021]. Available at https://olympics.com/athlete365/app/uploads/2021/04/21042021-Athlete-Expression-Consultation-PSE.pdf
IOC. Athlete Expression Consultation - IOC's Athletes Commission Report. Lausanne: IOC; 2020.
IOC. IOC Athletes’ Commission’s recommendations on Rule 50 and Athlete Expression at the Olympic Games fully endorsed by the IOC Executive Board [cited: April 20, 2022.]. olympics.com. April 4, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/ioc/news/ioc-athletes-commission-s-recommendations-on-rule-50-and-athlete-expression-at-the-olympic-games.
IOC. Athlete Expression Consultation - IOC's Athletes Commission Report. Lausanne: IOC; 2021.
IOC. Fundamental changes to the Olympic oath at Tokyo 2020 Opening Ceremony [cited April 22, 2022]. olympics.com. July 14, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/ioc/news/fundamental-changes-to-the-olympic-oath-at-tokyo-2020-opening-ceremony.
UN GA. Declaration on the right and responsibility of individuals, groups and organs of society to promote and protect universally recognized human rights and fundamental freedoms [cited Dec 04, 2022]. Available at https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/declaration-right-and-responsibility-individuals-groups-and
James M. The re-emergence of the athlete activist - Rule 50 and the precarious position of free speech under the IOC’s guidelines [cited March 21, 2022]. verfassungsblog.de. February 8, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://verfassungsblog.de/the-re-emergence-of-the-athlete-activist/.
UN. A/RES/64/3 - Observer status for the International Olympic Committee in the General Assembly. New York: UN; 2009.
Kerferd G. Protagoras’ doctrine of justice and virtue in the “Protagoras” of Plato. The Journal of Hellenic Studies. 1953; 73:42-45.
Rayan S. Teaching good virtues in Protagoras. Journal of Education and Human Development. 2014;3(4):345-351.
Roche M. The Olympics and "global citizenship". Citizenship Studies. 2002; 6(2): 165-181.
WPR. Neutral Countries 2022 [cited: April 26, 2022]. worldpopulationreview.com. 2022 [Online]. Available at https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/neutral-countries.
Lanni A. The laws of war in Ancient Greece. Law and History Review. 2008;26(3): 469-489.
Smith CF. History of the Peloponnesian War. Volume III: Books 5-6. Cambridge: Loeb Classical Library 110; 1921.
Müller L. Neutrality in world history. New York and London: Routledege; 2019.
TRT World. A look into Sweden and Finland’s Russia policy [cited: April 25, 2022]. trtworld.com. April 15, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/a-look-into-sweden-and-finland-s-russia-policy-56388.
Akiode OM. African feminists’ critique of just wars and the reality of African women in wars. In: Cordeiro-Rodrigues L, Singh D [ed.]. Comparative just war theory. Maryland, USA: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2020. p. 95-114.
Obama B. Remarks by the President at the acceptance of the Nobel Peace Prize. Washington (DC): The White House - Office of the Press Secretary. Available at https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-acceptance-nobel-peace-prize.
ItalianPostNews. Ukrainian war, Zelensky: “Whoever does not send weapons is responsible for the dead”. www.italianpost.news [cited April 22, 2022]. April 12, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.italianpost.news/ukrainian-war-zelensky-whoever-does-not-send-weapons-is-responsible-for-the-dead/.
swissinfo.ch. Swiss block German request to deliver ammo to Ukraine [cited April 25, 2022]. www.swissinfo.ch. April 24, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss-block-german-request-to-deliver-ammo-to-ukraine/47540394.
UN GA. A/Res/56/83 - Responsibility of states for internationally wrongful acts. New York: UN; 2001.
Bortoletto F. La Germania manda tank all’Ucraina, perché i pacifisti sono diventati interventisti [cited April 29, 2022.]. europa.today.it. April 26, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://europa.today.it/attualita/verdi-tedeschi-pacifismo-interventismo.html.
Joenniemi P. Models of neutrality: the traditional and modern. Cooperation and Conflict. 1988;23(1):53-67.
Worth K. The dichotomy of political power and political position at the Olympic Games [cited April 9, 2022]. blogs.hss.ed.ac.uk. February 16, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://www.blogs.hss.ed.ac.uk/sport-matters/2021/02/16/the-dichotomy-of-political-power-and-political-position-at-the-olympic-games/.
Hsiu-lien L, Tsai M, O’Hanlon M. Case studies of contemporary neutrality advocacy. In: Reginbogin HR, Lottaz P. Permanent neutrality - A model for peace, security, and justice. London: Lexington Books; 2020. p. 209-220.
Calculli M. Il mito dell'apolitico e il ritorno del conflitto [cited April 11, 2022]. Rivista il Mulino. December 20, 2019 [Online]. Available at https://www.rivistailmulino.it/a/il-mito-dell-apolitico-e-il-ritorno-del-conflitto.
Dzhantaev KM. International Olympic Committee and its regulations in the system of international law. RUDN - RUDN Journal of Law. 2011;1:135-146.
Liang YL. Reparation for injuries suffered in the service of the United Nations. The American Journal of International Law. 1949:43(3):460-478.
Crawford J. Brownlie's principles of public international law. Oxford (UK): Oxford University Press; 2019.
Ettinger, DJ. The legal status of the International Olympic Committee. Pace International Law Review, 1992;4:97-121.
IOC. Solidarity and political neutrality vital to the universality of the Olympic Games, President Bach tells ANOC General Assembly. Olympics [Cited April 9, 2022]. October 17, 2019 [Online]. Available at https://olympics.com/ioc/news/solidarity-and-political-neutrality-vital-to-the-universality-of-the-olympic-games-president-bach-tells-anoc-general-assembly.
Bach T. ANOC General Assembly: Doha 2019 [Cited April 9, 2022]. Speech. October 17, 2019 [Online]. Available at: Available at https://stillmed.olympics.com/media/Document%20Library/OlympicOrg/News/2019/10/2019-10-17-PRESIDENT-BACH-SPEECH-ANOC-GENERAL-ASSEMBLY-DOHA-2019-English.pdf?_ga=2.24168504.326306391.1649509030-582275379.1619729015.
Wade S. Russian invasion upends Olympic 'neutrality' — if it existed [cited: April 9, 2022]. CBC.CA. March 15, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.cbc.ca/sports/olympics/russia-invasion-upends-olympic-neutrality-if-it-existed-1.6385179.
Bach T. Statement on the occasion of the adoption of the resolution: “Building a peaceful and better world through sport and the Olympic ideal [cited: April 9, 2022]. Speech. November 6, 2013 [Online]. Available at:https://stillmed.olympic.org/Documents/IOC_President/2013-11-6_Speech_IOC_President_Bach-Olympic_Truce_adoption_Speech_4_November.pdf.
Isidori E, Reid H. Filosofia dello sport. Milano - Torino: Bruno Mondadori; 2011.
Coakley JJ. Sports in society: issues and controversies. New York (USA): Mc Graw Hill; 2021.
Armour N. Things we'd change in sports: It's time to stop playing national anthem at sporting events [cited April 30, 2022.]. USA Today. 2019 [Online]. Available at https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/columnist/nancy-armour/2019/03/14/national-anthem-star-spangled-banner-sports/2979056002/.
IOC. Legacy strategic approach moving forward. Lausanne: IOC; 2017.
CBC. Russian invasion upends Olympic 'neutrality' — if it existed [cited April 17, 2022]. www.cbc.ca. March 15, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.cbc.ca/sports/olympics/russia-invasion-upends-olympic-neutrality-if-it-existed-1.6385179.
Cravero R. Olimpismo tra sport, etica e politica [cited May 2, 2022]. www.filodiritto.com. March 8, 2022 [Online]. Available at https://www.filodiritto.com/olimpismo-tra-sport-etica-e-politica.
Bach T. Speech on the occasion of the Opening Ceremony 127th IOC Session. Monaco: IOC; 2014.
Proctor K. Social media and conflict: understanding risks and resilience. Mercy Corps. 2021;1:1-6.
Schweiger S, Cress U. Attitude confidence and source credibility in information foraging with social tags. PloS one. 2019;14(1):1-23.
Dieckmann NF et al. Public perceptions of expert disagreement: bias and incompetence or a complex and random world? Public Understanding of Science 2015;26(3):325-338.
Hameleers M, Van der Meer TGLA. Misinformation and polarization in a high-choice media environment: how effective are political fact-checkers? Communication Research. 2020;42(2):227-250.
Varakukalayil J. Social media and the politics of truth in the post truth-era. Journal of Media, Communication and Research. 2020;1:1-13.
Kyprianou A. How can athletes use social media effectively? [cited May 2, 2022] moneysmartathlete. October 30, 2019 [Online]. Available at https://moneysmartathlete.com/2019/10/30/how-can-athletes-use-social-media-effectively/.
Pfahl ME. Environmental sustainability rhetoric in sport. In: Ffahl ME. McCullough BP, Kellison TB. Routledge handbook of sport and the environment. London and New York: Routledge; 2020, p 121-134.
Grierson B. Athlete protests, “Rule 50,” and China’s collision course with the Beijing Olympics [cited April 19, 2022]. kpe.utoronto.ca. August 13, 2021 [Online]. Available at https://kpe.utoronto.ca/faculty-news/athlete-protests-rule-50-and-chinas-collision-course-beijing-olympics.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The authors authorize others to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format. Remix, transform, and create from the material. You may not use the material for commercial purposes.
